Anonymous

0 pts

Recent posts / uploads
No. 20128 - For lack of a better area...

Lyre - Wednesday, February 15th, 2012 - 6:45 PM

Hello all,
For some time now I have been considering the creation of a website or blog which gathers, organizes, and documents knowledge and research in the occult and esoteric. I've been planning on doing this both because there is a distinct lack of reputable sites on such matters, and because I have yet to find any sort of active forum (I mean, even sanc is practically dead) for the purpose.

The idea would be that this site would act as an academic journal of sorts: Entries submitted would be properly edited, and would be put under the scrutiny of peer review. Naturally, it would be wrong to say that I am the BEST person for such a job as reviewing any entries the site would get, but until I am able to verify the capability of others that would need to be the case.

My question is: Would you be interested in it? Would you make use of the site? Would you submit journals, studies, etc?

No. 20129 - Anonymous - February 15th, 2012 - 9:47 PM

Yes

No. 20130 - Goet Incubus - February 16th, 2012 - 2:31 AM

I'd certainly be interested, but I don't know if I'd have the time to contribute much.

There's also a potential problem with articles being peer-reviewed in a field where very little can be empirically proven: the "experts" brought in to peer-review may not be experts at all, but people with powerful or interesting personalities, and very quickly it could become a clique of people who use their editorial power to say what is and is not legitimate fields for study.

It's a great idea, though, so I don't mean to discourage you in the least.

No. 20132 - Anonymous - February 16th, 2012 - 5:58 AM

To be honest, if I'm looking for a good spook I usually go browsing on wikipedia. There's a real problem defining between 'real occult' and 'pseudo-occult', and wikipedia gets it all because it tolerates them both. An academic journal would require academic resources, something that can be in short supply.

I mean, if you really want to go ahead do it, but most people won't like to see all their favorite fears and horrors suddenly debunked by an academic know-it-all. A better project would be to approach some ufo-hunters or something and document their experiences as a wiki. At least on that ground people would view your work positively and respect your efforts, and you'll get involved with something you like.

No. 20162 - Anonymous - March 4th, 2012 - 3:44 PM

this sounds wonderful, i will help to the best of my ability. however i would like to know how you plan on organizing it.

i would like to see it be fairly neutral as well to some degree so it does not state only views that oppose or support a topic. in other words, add both to fully collect all information as well as questions left to be answered.

TOP

Post a Reply



  Add Image